Holder's decision to Mirandize the
Christmas bomber was bad enough. Telling the world he was talking again was
even worse
Security: The administration says the Christmas bomber is
now cooperating with authorities. We thought they got all the information he
had in a 50-minute chat. So just why are we letting our enemies know he's
talking?
In any war, it's vitally important that you know what your enemy is
planning and doing, just as it's important that your actions and plans remain
secret. And when you know about your enemy's plans it's important they don't
know that you know.
We were told not to worry when the Christmas bomber, Umar Farouk
Abdulmutallab, was taken into custody and Mirandized almost immediately. We
were told we got all the information he had in 50 minutes. Larry King has done
longer and better interviews.
Now the story has changed. Apparently we didn't get all the information he
had, for the administration has publicly announced that Mr. Abdulmutallab is
now cooperating with authorities, presumably telling us what he really knows
about the intentions of al-Qaida in the Arabian Peninsula. If so, that is good
news.
What's not so good news is that to score political points, the
administration has told the world and al-Qaida that we are learning what
Abdulmutallab knows, and now al-Qaida will know we know what he knows. They
will change their plans, move their assets and attempt to thwart any U.S.
action based on any valuable information he may be providing.
Abdulmutallab has been providing information in recent days, an
administration official said last Tuesday on condition of anonymity. This
announcement was presumably made to make the point that the administration's
decision to abandon enhanced interrogation techniques was justified.
This announcement made Sen. Christopher Bond, R-Mo., justifiably furious.
Bond promptly dashed off a letter of protest to President Barack Obama. In the
letter he noted that on Feb. 1 the leadership of the Senate Intelligence
Committee received notice from the Federal Bureau of Investigation concerning
Abdulmutallab's recent willingness to provide critical information.
The problem, Bond said, was that a short 24 hours later "White House staff
assembled members of the media to announce Abdulmutallab's cooperation and to
laud the events that led to his decision to cooperate with law enforcement
personnel. This information immediately hit the airwaves globally, and, no
doubt, reached the ears of our enemies abroad."
This is an unconscionable betrayal of the public trust, one that puts
American lives and national security at risk, jeopardizes future American
actions and gives our terrorist enemies an unnecessary and dangerous heads-up.
"FBI officials," Bond wrote, "stressed to me the importance of not
disclosing the fact of (Abdulmutallab's) cooperation in order to protect
on-going and follow-on operations to neutralize additional threats to the
American public; FBI Director Robert Mueller personally stressed to me that
keeping the fact of (Abdulmutallab's) cooperation secret was vital to prevent
future attacks against the United States."
Atty. Gen. Eric Holder has admitted and defended his decision to Mirandize
Abdulmutallab almost immediately and proceed to a criminal trial. He has said
he is merely following the precedent established by President George W. Bush
in his handling of shoe bomber Richard Reid. That is a bogus comparison.
Reid was arrested in December 2001 in the aftermath of 9/11 when the
anti-terror apparatus we have now was not yet fully in place. There were no
military commissions or tribunals to process his case. There is today no
reason to treat terrorist acts as criminal acts. There is certainly no reason
to blab about how we are operating and what we are learning to the world and
our enemies.
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the 9/11 architect, and the Christmas bomber are
enemy combatants. They should be brought before military tribunals as enemy
soldiers in a terrorist war on the United States. Their fate should be no
different than that of the Nazi saboteurs who landed on our shores during
World War II.
And this administration and Atty. Gen. Eric Holder should learn to keep
their big mouths shut.