New oil-spill compensation
czar Kenneth Feinberg controls a $20 billion victims’ fund that
represents yet another power-grab by the White House...
Energy: The administration strong-armed BP into
placing billions into a fund that is supposed to compensate Gulf
oil-spill victims. Nothing wrong with making victims whole, but isn't
that what courts are for?
During the BP executives' brief meeting Wednesday with President
Obama, they agreed to set aside $20 billion into an escrow account that
will be used to pay for damage to businesses and individuals caused by
the Deepwater Horizon oil spill. The funds are to be distributed by a
third party who supposedly will be nonbiased.
That party is Kenneth Feinberg, last seen serving as the
administration's pay czar. And that smell in the Gulf? It isn't the
sulfurous odor of spilled crude. Just the rancid stench of politics.
Setting up the office of a pay czar, officially known as "special
master for compensation," was another of this administration's many
violations of the private sector. The position was established to
oversee executive pay at companies that took bailouts.
But the zealous Feinberg, who demanded that Bank of America CEO Ken
Lewis work for free, seemed ready at any time to increase the office's
authority and begin dictating corporate salaries beyond those in the
bailed-out companies.
As pay czar, Feinberg, a one-time chief of staff for the late Sen.
Ted Kennedy who was recommended to Obama for his pay-czar gig by
Democratic Sen. Chris Dodd of Connecticut, felt it was his duty to send
a message to Wall Street. It's a line of thinking perfectly in sync with
this administration's eagerness to impose government authority over the
private sector.
The president might be confident that Feinberg "will assure that
claims are administered as quickly, as fairly and as transparently as
possible." But we're not. The job shouldn't be a forum for expressing
populist outrage toward the vilified oil industry. Nor is it supposed to
be a mechanism for handing out political favors.
The only fair way to handle the compensation process is through the
judicial system. Our civil courts were designed to settle disputes
between private citizens and compensate victims of harm.
The courts have, until they were hijacked by predatory lawyers from
the trial bar, generally performed their duty well.
For all its (compelled) generosity, BP might yet find itself tangled
in this system. Under the terms of the agreement, the fund does not
"supersede either individuals' rights or states' rights" to sue in
court, leaving the company exposed to the civil liability version of
double jeopardy.
It's not far-fetched at all to interpret this exception as both a
political play and a clear message to the trial lawyers who are eyeing
energy as the next industry to get rich from.
The administration has also emphasized that the $20 billion amount is
not a cap. This strongly suggests the White House isn't finished
plundering BP and its shareholders.
We understand that, in our litigation system, the wheels of justice
often roll on as if the tires were flat — or worse, square. But it is
our system and it guards against the executive branch trying to
establish justice as a monarch would, by fiat and political favors. It
should not be bypassed for convenience or political gain.
Texas Republican Rep. Joe Barton is right to characterize the $20
billion fund a "shakedown," just as GOP Rep. Michele Bachmann of
Minnesota is correct in calling it a "redistribution-of-wealth fund" and
a "gateway for more government control."
This White House is treading yet again on ground that it should stay
away from. That the infringement has gone this far is a regret. If it
goes any further, it will be a tragedy.