Entitlements: While a massive health care entitlement is
fashioned in secret, another one, Social Security, is running deficits decades
earlier than expected. We've been kicking the can down the road. We're out of
road.
As Bernie Madoff found out, any Ponzi scheme depends on a continuous inflow
of new cash and new customers or the ever-expanding pyramid will totter and
collapse. Social Security, dependent as it was on new workers paying the
expanding benefits of retirees, is about to, much sooner than expected.
As Ed Morrissey over at HotAir.com reminds us, Peter Orszag, now director
of the Office of Management and Budget, predicted as director of the
Congressional Budget Office in August 2008 that no one needed to worry about
Social Security. "CBO projects that outlays will first exceed revenues in 2019
and that the Social Security trust funds will be exhausted in 2049," we were
told.
As the baby boomers have started retiring and the economy has collapsed,
that day of reckoning is here. The Social Security Administration's Office of
the Chief Actuary finally got around to posting detailed November numbers, and
they aren't pretty.
The combined OASDI (Old-Age Survivors and Disability Insurance) "Trust"
Funds recorded a nearly $6 billion primary deficit for November, the worst
monthly performance since records began in 1987. The 12-month OASDI primary
surplus was only $9.598 billion, also the worst 12-month performance on
record.
Only the fact there will be no cost-of-living increase in 2010 may save
OASDI from running a primary deficit this year. But continued economic
doldrums coupled with the economy-killing socialization of health care, higher
taxes, rising deficits and the still-looming catastrophe known as
cap-and-trade may cause our house of Social Security cards to collapse long
before sea levels begin to rise.
When you consider just disability income (DI), the picture looks even
bleaker. For the 50th straight month, going back to October 2005, the DI Fund
ran a yearly deficit, this time a record $21 billion.
At least one part of Orszag's prophecy is coming true: "Social Security's
revenues each year are greater than its outlays, but as the baby-boom
generation (people born between 1946 and 1964) continues to age, growth in the
number of Social Security beneficiaries will accelerate, and outlays will grow
substantially faster than revenues."
That trend has accelerated to the point of collapse.
Private, insurance company-run annuity plans are legally required to pay
you what was promised, when it was promised, and to maintain assets sufficient
to redeem those promises. Social Security is not. Any insurance company CEO
that ran a Ponzi scheme like Social Security would soon be incarcerated for
fraud.
Opponents of the partial privatization proposed by President George W. Bush
cited the variability in the stock market as a looming disaster and probably
would say "I told you so" considering the recent market troubles. But at least
retirees would still have real money, their money, in real accounts. They
wouldn't be dependent on government IOU's and the hoped-for contributions of
others.
We have a looming disaster on our hands.
Social Security has been called the "third rail" of American politics.
Well, this train is running off the rails, and someone better touch it before
momma gets thrown from it.